China Jet’s Nosedive From 29,000 Feet Baffles Crash Specialists
By Alan Levin
The China Eastern Airlines Corp. jet was flying a normal route to Guangzhou when it suddenly nosed over at cruise altitude and dove.
That’s about all that is known for certain about the unusual crash that almost certainly killed all 132 people aboard the aircraft Monday in China’s worst commercial aviation accident in more than a decade.
While there have been a handful of crashes in which an airliner plunged from cruising altitude, few, if any, fit the extreme profile of the Boeing Co. 737-800 as it pointed steeply toward the ground, according to veteran crash investigators and previous accident reports.
“It’s an odd profile,” said John Cox, an aviation safety consultant and former 737 pilot. “It’s hard to get the airplane to do this.”
As investigators search for the plane’s two crash-proof recorders and begin poring over clues, they will be trying to determine why the jet made such an abrupt and severe dive, which sets it apart from earlier accidents. They will be looking at the wreckage pattern to ensure the plane didn’t break up in flight, the weather the plane encountered, any hints of possible malfunctions and detailed profiles of the crew.
The so-called black box recorders haven’t been recovered, state-backed news agency Xinhua reported. The investigation will be difficult, Zhu Tao, an official with China’s Civil Aviation Administration, said at a press briefing Tuesday at the end of the first full day of searching through the wreckage. Zhu described a devastating impact and hilly terrain in the impact zone.
Air traffic controllers tried multiple times to reach pilots of doomed China Eastern Flight 5735 after it began its deadly dive on Monday but received no response, Zhu said.
Flight MU5735 was at about 29,000 feet (8,839.2 meters) altitude roughly 100 miles (160.93 kilometers) from its destination — about the point at which the pilots would begin descending to land — when it started plunging at a far greater rate than normal.
Instead of gradually dropping by a few thousand feet per minute — which produces a barely detectable sensation for passengers — it began falling at more than 30,000 feet per minute within seconds, according to tracking data logged by Flightradar24.
Overall, it plunged almost 26,000 feet in the span of roughly 1 minute, 35 seconds, the data track showed.
The plane’s dive appeared to have halted for about 10 seconds and it climbed briefly, adding an unusual twist to the scenario. But the Flightradar24 track, which is based on radio transmissions from the plane, then showed it resuming a steep plunge.
“It’s very odd,” said Jeff Guzzetti, the former accident investigation chief for U.S. Federal Aviation Administration.
While cautioning that the Flightradar24 data is preliminary, Guzzetti and Cox said the relatively straight track taken by the jet and the fact that its transponders were still broadcasting suggests that it didn’t break up in flight, as has been seen in some terrorist bombings.
Surveillance Video
A surveillance video appearing to capture the plane in its final moments showed it in a steep dive toward the ground. Chinese media outlet The Paper said it had verified that the video was shot by a mining company near where the jet impacted, but its authenticity couldn’t be independently verified.
Crash in China
The China Eastern flight was headed to Guangzhou from Kunming
For example, Air France Flight 447, which went down in the Atlantic Ocean on June 1, 2009, fell much slower and more erratically after speed sensors iced up and pilots became confused, according to France’s Bureau of Enquiry and Analysis for Civil Aviation Safety. All 228 people aboard the Airbus SE A330 died.
Though it went down from a much lower altitude, an Atlas Air Worldwide Holdings Inc. cargo jet dove suddenly into a marsh near Houston on Feb. 23, 2019. In that case, the copilot became disoriented and pointed the nose toward the ground, the U.S. National Transportation Safety Board found. Its descent occurred over a much shorter period of time and it wasn’t falling as fast the China Eastern plane.
Another crash that was similar occurred on Dec. 19, 1997, when a pilot on a Silk Air 737-300 carrying 104 people dove into a river in Indonesia, killing everyone aboard. It was falling at more than 38,000 feet per minute, according to that nation’s National Transportation Safety Committee.
Too Soon for Conclusions
A pilot most likely crashed that plane deliberately, the NTSB concluded. The plane’s cockpit and flight-data recorder systems were mysteriously shut off, so detailed information about the trajectory of the dive weren’t available.
It’s far too early to draw conclusions on what led to the China Eastern crash, said Benjamin Berman, a former NTSB investigator who also flew 737s.
It’s possible to come up with many scenarios for some type of malfunction, pilot miscues or some combination that led to the plunge, Berman said.
But none of them seem very likely. He echoed what Cox and Guzzetti said: The 737-800, like other jetliners, is designed so that it won’t normally dive at steep angles.
That means it would likely take an extreme effort by a pilot or a highly unusual malfunction, he said.
Many things can cause at least the start of a dive — from a pilot suffering a heart attack and slumping onto the control column to a failure of the motor used to help raise and lower the nose. But they would tend to be more short-lived or there are easy ways for pilots to counteract such failures, he said.
“You need something to hold the nose down,” Berman said.
