‘Transparency Has Been Killed by Obstruction’ as Officials flout FOI Rules

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn
Share on pinterest
Pinterest
Share on whatsapp
WhatsApp
Share on telegram
Telegram

Where Ted Talks end, Truth Talks begin.
Defending democracy by defending free speech

Opinion pieces don’t necessarily reflect the position of our news site but of our Opinion writers.

‘Transparency Has Been Killed by Obstruction’ as Officials flout FOI Rules

By David Crowe

Federal officials are flouting their own rules by rejecting fair requests to release documents and disclose the reasons for sweeping decisions, sparking a new warning about a “culture of secrecy” in politics and government.

The decisions have created a “clogged and slow” system that drags out many of the 35,000 requests from Australians under the Freedom of Information Act each year, with a soaring number of outright rejections.


The report found a “culture of secrecy” in politics and government

A new report by the Centre for Public Integrity reveals a 50 per cent increase over the past decade in the proportion of FOI requests that have been refused in full each year and concludes the trend is denying Australians a basic right in making the government accountable for its actions.

“There is a degree of lawlessness about all of this – the research shows that close to one in four government decisions failed to comply with statutory deadlines,” write barrister Geoffrey Watson, SC, and researcher Max Douglass about the new findings.

Prime Minister Anthony Albanese came to power in May with a pledge to be more transparent after he accused his predecessor, Scott Morrison, of cloaking his government in secrecy.

The new report, to be issued on Monday, shows that 1.3 per cent of all FOI requests were decided more than 90 days late a decade ago, but the number had reached 12.4 per cent last year.

While the FOI Act was passed in 1982 with an expectation that decisions would take 30 days, the new research finds that almost half of all requests are being resolved outside the statutory timeframe.

In a close examination of FOI decisions and appeals, the study found many valid claims were being denied or delayed when they could have succeeded with faster access to an appeal to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

A key factor, the researchers found, was that the first step in an appeal against a government department was to the Office of the Australian Information Commissioner, an agency that does not have enough staff to decide matters quickly and slows the process of taking the case to the AAT.

Former Commonwealth ombudsman John McMillan warned in 2019 the government’s approach to FOI was undermining transparency and breaching the spirit of federal law, but decisions have become slower in recent years.

While the media uses FOI law to seek policy documents, most applications are from individuals and 77 per cent of all requests last year were for personal information. The majority of requests each year go to the Department of Home Affairs and Services Australia regarding decisions that have an impact on individuals.

The Centre for Public Integrity is a not-for-profit think tank with directors including former NSW Supreme Court judge Anthony Whealy, QC, former Victorian Court of Appeal judge Stephen Charles, QC, University of Melbourne professor Joo Cheong Tham and University of NSW professor Gabrielle Appleby.

Bret Walker SC, a leading barrister, said Australians should be able to find out about government decisions.

“Without knowing about what government is doing, the idea of democracy is defeated,” he said.

“The desire for secrecy has gone way beyond acceptable limits on the part of governments in this country. The supposed benefits of freedom of information legislation have nearly been destroyed by recalcitrant administrators and counterproductive exemptions.”

With the government working on draft laws to create a national integrity commission, campaigners for FOI reform want Attorney-General Mark Dreyfus to commit to greater transparency to honour the assurances he and Albanese made before the election.

Former independent senator Rex Patrick said he had five FOI requests that have taken more than two years to be resolved and several more that have taken almost three years.

The new report comes with seven recommendations including more resources for the Office of the Information Commissioner to rule on appeals and work across the federal government on a “pro-disclosure” culture.

The report recommends disciplinary sanctions when federal officials repeatedly make decisions that are overturned on appeal because they are contrary to FOI law, saying this could also extend to people who “direct or influence them” to make these decisions. It adds that criminal sanctions might also be available.

It recommends a cross-party committee in parliament to make government agencies more accountable for their FOI decisions and it seeks a change in the law so departments do not invalidate requests for information when there is a change of government or minister.

“The facts establish that transparency has been killed by pure bloody-minded obstruction,” write Watson and Douglass in The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age on Monday.

“The FOI scheme is now moribund. Claims of exemption are wantonly deployed to defeat transparency and accountability. The Morrison government has been the worst example of this – it was obsessed with secrecy.

“The research shows that the exemption claims being made by the federal government are frequently bogus. Close to half of the claims for exemption made by government are overturned on appeal. That is a shocking figure – it really demonstrates that the government is consistently wrong.”

Opinion pieces don’t necessarily reflect the position of our news site but of our Opinion writers.

*Note We Deliberately Miss Spell Some Words or Add Capital Letters To Get Around Big Tech Censoring.

Support the ANR from as little as $50 – it only takes a minute. If you can, please consider supporting us with a regular amount each month. Thank you.

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn
Share on pinterest
Pinterest
Share on whatsapp
WhatsApp
Share on telegram
Telegram

Related News

Where Ted Talks end, Truth Talks begin.
Defending democracy by defending free speech

Subscribe for free to our ANR news emails and access 2 free ebooks plus Reports to share with family and friends about Covid fraud and the danger of the vaccines.

Help us help defend free speech and save democracy from the World Economic Forum planned Totalitarian Great Reset.

and help us expose the Covid Fraudsters

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Documentary: Died Suddenly (2022)

Play Video

McIntyre Report
Political Talk Show

Episode 155

Episode 154

How you can advertise on Truthbook.social

Help us help defend free speech and save democracy from the World Economic Forum planned Totalitarian Great Reset.

and help us expose the Covid Fraudsters

Ukraine. Military Summary And Analysis 02.12.2022

Raw Report

Ryan Jackson Saw show

in USD

in AUD

in GBP

in CAD

Jamie McIntyre

ANR on

Currency Exchange Rates in AUD

Live and updated every minute of the day

Nurses Speak Out

Get our free News Emails on latest articles, alerts and solutions for both legal templates and ways to help fight back against the Globalists vax Mandates , and health resources to boost your immune system and ways to Protect from deadly EMF 5G radiation and more.

FREE E-BOOKS AND REPORTS ALSO

ANR Meme Report

with Nadine Roberts

Episode 002

21st Century Political System

Play Video

Editor's Pick

Thank you for visiting the
Australian National Review

To continue accessing more articles for free simply enter your email address

Watch Full Documentary

TruthTalks business partnership

Ideal for freedom movement activists, influencers, digital nomads, content creators and those who refuse to be silenced and want to expose the Globalists Agenda .

Truth Talks Partner Opportunity

Click here to learn more about this opportunity and how 12 online clients per year can earn you $203,000 USD per annum

Download the Full PDF - THE COVID-19 FRAUD & WAR ON HUMANITY