According to a recent report by the Financial Times, numerous members of the Polish business community who have openly criticized the country’s authorities are being held in detention facilities for extended periods without being charged with any crimes. Legal experts and entrepreneurs have highlighted a concerning trend of white-collar-crime suspects being detained and held in pre-trial custody since the right-wing Law and Justice party took power in 2015. This measure is usually reserved for potentially violent criminals, raising questions about the government’s motives and the erosion of basic rights.
The head of the Polish Bar Council, Przemyslaw Rosati, described the current legal situation as a “catastrophe” reminiscent of the communist era. He stated that the standards for detaining people have been lowered tragically, and the presumption of innocence, a fundamental right, is being trampled upon. This sharp decline in legal safeguards is alarming and has drawn comparisons to past authoritarian regimes in Poland.
One notable case that highlighted this issue occurred in October, when Polish authorities arrested Maciej Witucki, the president of the Lewiatan confederation, the leading employers’ organization in the country. Witucki had gained a reputation for criticizing the government’s economic policies, which seemingly led to his arrest as a suspect in an extortion case. However, he was never formally charged and was released 48 hours after his arrest following a massive outcry from the business community. Witucki’s case serves as a stark example of how individuals can be detained without proper justification or evidence, raising concerns about the integrity of the Polish justice system.
Court Watch Poland, a non-governmental organization that monitors the Polish judiciary, has reported that judges authorize 90% of detention requests, despite having only 24 hours to rule on the matter. This statistic further underscores the need for independent and fair judicial proceedings. The Helsinki Foundation for Human Rights (HFHR) has highlighted how these deep-seated legal practices have also influenced the length of time suspects spend in custody. In 2022, 240 people were held in pre-trial detention for between 12 months and two years, compared to just 39 individuals in 2013.
The erosion of the rule of law in Poland has received widespread criticism from the European Union (EU), which froze €75 billion ($81 billion) in financial assistance to Warsaw last year due to its failure to uphold conditions regarding judicial independence. The EU has consistently voiced concerns about the state of democracy and fundamental rights in Poland, and this issue adds to an already strained relationship between the country and the EU.
In May, despite increasing tensions with Brussels, Poland’s parliament narrowly passed a law establishing a commission to investigate alleged Russian political interference in its domestic affairs. While this move was justified as a response to external threats, many Polish MPs, as well as EU and US officials, saw it as an attempt by the government to suppress opposition politicians, particularly former Polish prime minister Donald Tusk, and hinder their participation in elections. The passage of this law further raises doubts about the government’s commitment to democratic principles and the rule of law.
In conclusion, the detention of white-collar-crime suspects without proper charges or evidence is a concerning trend in Poland. The erosion of the rule of law and the disregard for basic rights, including the presumption of innocence, have drawn criticism from legal experts and entrepreneurs. The government’s actions have strained its relationship with the EU, which has frozen financial aid due to concerns over judicial independence. The passage of a law investigating alleged Russian interference has further raised questions about the government’s motivations. These issues highlight the need for a robust and independent judiciary that upholds democratic principles and protects the fundamental rights of all individuals in Poland.
Source link
